Raid on the Sun: Inside Israel's Secret Campaign that Denied Saddam the Bomb
Average customer rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars
  • RICK SHAQ GOLDSTEIN SAYS: "TRUTH IS STRANGER THAN FICTION!" "THIS COULD BE THE BLUE PRINT FOR IRAN!"
  • This book is a fast and entertaining read
  • Incredible
  • Exciting
  • Incredible tale!
Raid on the Sun: Inside Israel's Secret Campaign that Denied Saddam the Bomb
Rodger Claire
Manufacturer: Broadway
ProductGroup: Book
Binding: Paperback

GeneralGeneral | Middle East | History | Subjects | Books
IsraelIsrael | Middle East | History | Subjects | Books
Intelligence & EspionageIntelligence & Espionage | Military | History | Subjects | Books
GeneralGeneral | Politics | Nonfiction | Subjects | Books
International SecurityInternational Security | Freedom & Security | Politics | Nonfiction | Subjects | Books
Similar Items:
  1. The Yom Kippur War: The Epic Encounter That Transformed the Middle East The Yom Kippur War: The Epic Encounter That Transformed the Middle East
  2. Israel's Secret Wars: A History of Israel's Intelligence Services Israel's Secret Wars: A History of Israel's Intelligence Services
  3. The Hunt For The Engineer: The Inside Story of How Isral's Counterterrorist Forces Tracked and Killed the Hamas Master Bomber The Hunt For The Engineer: The Inside Story of How Isral's Counterterrorist Forces Tracked and Killed the Hamas Master Bomber
  4. Six Days of War: June 1967 and the Making of the Modern Middle East Six Days of War: June 1967 and the Making of the Modern Middle East
  5. Vengeance: The True Story of an Israeli Counter-Terrorist Team Vengeance: The True Story of an Israeli Counter-Terrorist Team

ASIN: 0767914252
Release Date: 2005-03-01

Book Description

The first authorized inside account of one of the most daring—and successful—military operations in recent history

From the earliest days of his dictatorship, Saddam Hussein had vowed to destroy Israel. So when France sold Iraq a top-of-the-line nuclear reactor in 1975, the Israelis were justifiably concerned—especially when they discovered that Iraqi scientists had already formulated a secret program to extract weapons-grade plutonium from the reactor, a first critical step in creating an atomic bomb. The reactor formed the heart of a huge nuclear plant situated twelve miles from Baghdad, 1,100 kilometers from Tel Aviv. By 1981, the reactor was on the verge of becoming “hot,” and Israeli Prime Minister Menachem Begin knew he would have to confront its deadly potential. He turned to Israeli Air Force commander General David Ivry to secretly plan a daring surgical strike on the reactor—a never-before-contemplated mission that would prove to be one of the most remarkable military operations of all time.

Written with the full and exclusive cooperation of the Israeli Air Force high command, General Ivry (ret.), and all of the eight mission pilots (including Ilan Ramon, who become Israel’s first astronaut and perished tragically in the shuttle Columbia disaster), Raid on the Sun tells the extraordinary story of how Israel plotted the unthinkable: defying its U.S. and European allies to eliminate Iraq’s nuclear threat. In the tradition of Black Hawk Down, journalist Rodger Claire re-creates a gripping tale of personal sacrifice and survival, of young pilots who trained in the United States on the then-new, radically sophisticated F-16 fighter bombers, then faced a nearly insurmountable challenge: how to fly the 1,000-plus-kilometer mission to Baghdad and back on one tank of fuel. He recounts Israeli intelligence’s incredible “black ops” to sabotage construction on the French reactor and eliminate Iraqi nuclear scientists, and he gives the reader a pilot’s-eye view of the action on June 7, 1981, when the planes roared off a runway on the Sinai Peninsula for the first successful destruction of a nuclear reactor in history.

Download Description

The first authorized inside account of one of the most daring—and successful—military operations in recent history

From the earliest days of his dictatorship, Saddam Hussein had vowed to destroy Israel. So when France sold Iraq a top-of-the-line nuclear reactor in 1975, the Israelis were justifiably concerned—especially when they discovered that Iraqi scientists had already formulated a secret program to extract weapons-grade plutonium from the reactor, a first critical step in creating an atomic bomb.

The reactor formed the heart of a huge nuclear plant situated twelve miles from Baghdad, 1,100 kilometers from Tel Aviv. By 1981, the reactor was on the verge of becoming "hot," and Israeli Prime Minister Menachem Begin knew he would have to confront its deadly potential. He turned to Israeli Air Force commander General David Ivry to secretly plan a daring surgical strike on the reactor—a never-before-contemplated mission that would prove to be one of the most remarkable military operations of all time.

Written with the full and exclusive cooperation of the Israeli Air Force high command, General Ivry (ret.), and all of the eight mission pilots (including Ilan Ramon, who become Israel's first astronaut and perished tragically in the shuttle Columbia disaster), Raid on the Sun tells the extraordinary story of how Israel plotted the unthinkable: defying its U.S. and European allies to eliminate Iraq's nuclear threat.

In the tradition of Black Hawk Down, journalist Rodger Claire re-creates a gripping tale of personal sacrifice and survival, of young pilots who trained in the United States on the then-new, radically sophisticated F-16 fighter bombers, then faced a nearly insurmountable challenge: how to fly the 1,000-plus-kilometer mission to Baghdad and back on one tank of fuel. He recounts Israeli intelligence's incredible "black ops" to sabotage construction on the French reactor and eliminate Iraqi nuclear scientists, and he gives the reader a pilot's-eye view of the action on June 7, 1981, when the planes roared off a runway on the Sinai Peninsula for the first successful destruction of a nuclear reactor in history.


"Rodger Claire handles a complex story with ease and assurance. Infused with an understanding of the pilots and their historical mission, Raid on the Sun illustrates how what they achieved for Israel was as vital as that earlier flight of the Enola Gay to Hiroshima to end World War Two. Claire has created a patient, scrupulous story that still unfolds with the pace and verve of a thriller. Don't wait for the movie of the book. Buy it now."
    GORDON THOMAS, AUTHOR OF GIDEON'S SPIES: MOSSAD'S SECRET WARRIORS

"Raid on the Sun is an extraordinary look into the most secret, and perhaps the finest, air force on the planet. It is also a blistering indictment of the international arms industry that sells modern weapons to anyone with money. Raid on the Sun is required reading for everyone in the age of terror."
   STEPHEN COONTS, AUTHOR OF FLIGHT OF THE INTRUDER

"A stunning eye-opener, shocking you with the realization of the enormous service the Israeli Air Force rendered the free world with its 1981 attack on Saddam Hussein's nuclear facility. Claire went right to the source—the Israeli pilots who flew the mission—to tell in colorful detail the full story of this historic strike."
    Customer Reviews:

5 out of 5 stars RICK SHAQ GOLDSTEIN SAYS: "TRUTH IS STRANGER THAN FICTION!" "THIS COULD BE THE BLUE PRINT FOR IRAN!".......2007-06-16

I'm sure you've heard the phrase: "I COULDN'T PUT THIS BOOK DOWN, AND READ IT COVER TO COVER!" This book for me defined that, and if there really is a dictionary, (With famous phrases.) with the proverbial picture next to it, this book should be next to that phrase! This "TRUE" story, written over twenty years after the unbelievable Israeli bombing mission to destroy Iraq's nuclear facility, is too fantastic to believe. Why, was this in depth story never told before you may ask? Because Israel refused to talk about it, or release classified information. But now, this book was written with the "FULL" and exclusive cooperation, of the Israeli Air Force high command. I don't want to give away too much of the book, but it actually gives you information, way ahead of the actual mission also. Such as, Saddam Hussein's childhood and early years, that led and shaped him into the monster he became, as with the building of this nuclear reactor, and the vow to blow Israel off the face of the earth. It traces all the secret training in Israel, leading up to the historic raid. A titillating, page, early in the book, is an organization chart, of all the Israeli leaders in June 1981, and how they voted, pro or con, for the approval of the mission. This story makes James Bond look like The Hardy Boys. During the training of the pilots, Israel had to dismantle part of the jets, to lower the weight, so they would use less fuel, since the round trip mission from Israel to Iraq and back, had to be done with no refueling. Since I am not a pilot, but fly constantly. I almost felt like I was a passenger, along with the brave Israeli pilots, as they had to fly so close to the ground (100 FEET!) for 600 MILES over Saudi Arabia, to stay under the radar. The pilots had to contend with the rising heat from the desert, that adversely affected the jets. There were also things going on outside of Israel, that had to be done, while training was still taking place, to insure that the Iraqi nuclear reactor wouldn't go "live", before the Israeli plan was ready to go into action! These events were so unbelievable, that if you saw it in an Arnold Schwartzenagger, or Clint Eastwood movie, you wouldn't believe it! A beautiful blonde, pretending to be hit by a car, in front of a French Security gate, where the final pieces of the nuclear reactor were being manufactured. With this "blonde" diversion, Israeli agents got into the French manufacturing facility, to sabotage the piece, needed to finish the reactor. Thereby giving Israeli pilots, and masterminds, more time to prepare. The blowing up of an Italian apartment, owned by a supplier of parts to Iraq, as a warning not to supply the reactor. Of course, credit for the explosion was given to someone else. I could go on and on, but, that's why I said earlier, you can't put the book down. I want to tell you more, because it's unbelievable, but just go buy the book, and then I guarantee you, you'll want to tell someone else too. P.S. This could be a blue print for Iran. Wait and see?!

4 out of 5 stars This book is a fast and entertaining read.......2007-03-19

If you are interested in military and middle east history, this may be a book for you. It has a good pace and is very easy reading. The pace of the book is not quite as fast as BlackHawk Down, but better than Bowden's other book, Killing Pablo. It almost has that 'reads like fiction' feel. I agree though, with one of the other posters comments that I read, and that is that there are alot of technical details that are not correct, (like "heat seeking Sparrow's") which does beg the question of whether or not he did not did not get all the facts right. But none the less, still a fun read and if even only half of it is right, its still an amazing story. I will highly recommend this book to my friends.

5 out of 5 stars Incredible.......2007-02-24

Raid on the Sun describes the events leading up to to the 1981 raid on the Osirik reactor. It's a solid written, highly readable book. The book jacket nails it dead on by saying that this is something you'd see in a Hollywood thriller - a small country up against incredible odds both technologically and politically and overcoming them. I highly recommend it.

Reading some of the other reviews, I would like to point out that the comparisons to the current situation with Iran are perfunctory at best. Iran's nuclear facilities are deep underground, spread out in multiple locations over a large land mass, many cynically located under civilian areas such as schools. The Iranians learned many lessons from "the raid on the sun." There are three options on the table at this point from the Israeli perspective:

1. Wait and hope the U.S. bombs Iran. It's not looking like this is going to happen, as Bush probably needs Congress's authorization , and they most likely will not give it considering how Iraq is going. Furthermore, Bush has given authorization to Rice and the State Department to try to negotiate. Looks like Cheney and the neo-cons have lost power. Yet Israel will give it until the end of the year at least, according to leaked reports.

2. Attack Iran. Given how spread out the facilities are and Israel's capabilities, they have the ability to attack the three or four most important nuclear targets but not much more, which will delay the nuclear program for a number of years but not stop it. Iran will retaliate heavily, as well as its proxies Syria, Hezbollah and Hamas. The Tel Aviv skyscrapers will almost certainly be hit; there will be a huge fallout internationally; and Israel's economy will go to hell.

3. Do nothing, which is of course the worst decision, given Ahmadinejad's statements about Israel and the apocalyptic beliefs of Shiite Islam.

We'll have to wait and see, eh? By the way, I highly recommend that you check out the MIT paper, "Osirak Redux? Assessing Israeli capabilities to Destroy Iranian Nuclear Facilities" by Whitney Raas and Austin Long, which is where the estimates from #2 come from.

5 out of 5 stars Exciting .......2006-11-04

This is a great read. I found my heart pounding as these great pilots defended their country against this great evil.

5 out of 5 stars Incredible tale!.......2006-09-11

This is an incredible story of the June 7, 1981, operation that took out Saddam Hussein's nuclear reactor and, as a result, probably alone kept him from obtaining a nuclear weapon.

Astonishingly, the brave Israeli pilots took 8 F-16's in to enemy territory and all returned home safely. This book details the planning and exeuction of this operation from start to finish.

This is a very good read, especially given the happenings of recent years in that region. Despite the almost unanimous international criticism Israel received for this operation, we probably have those brave men and women of the IDF to thank today for the fact that the world has not yet experienced a nuclear holocaust at the hands of a mad tyrant.
Raid on the Sun: Inside Israel's Secret Campaign That Denied Saddam the Bomb
Average customer rating: Not rated
    Raid on the Sun: Inside Israel's Secret Campaign That Denied Saddam the Bomb

    Manufacturer: Books on Tape
    ProductGroup: Book
    Binding: Audio CD
    ASIN: 1415901058

    Product Description

    8 cds - Unabridged
    Raid on the Sun: Inside Israel's Secret Campaign That Denied Saddam the Bomb.(Brief Article)(Book Review) : An article from: Air & Space Power Journal
    Average customer rating: Not rated
      Raid on the Sun: Inside Israel's Secret Campaign That Denied Saddam the Bomb.(Brief Article)(Book Review) : An article from: Air & Space Power Journal
      J. Rick Rosales
      Manufacturer: Thomson Gale
      ProductGroup: Book
      Binding: Digital

      NonfictionNonfiction | Subjects | Books | Audiobooks | Automotive | Books on CD | Books on Cassette | Crime & Criminals | Current Events | Economics | Education | Foreign Language Nonfiction | Government | Holidays | Law | Philosophy | Politics | Social Sciences | Transportation | True Accounts | Urban Planning & Development | Women's Studies
      GeneralGeneral | Science | Subjects | Books
      Science & TechnologyScience & Technology | Subjects | e-Docs | Formats | Books
      GeneralGeneral | Nonfiction | HTML | Formats | e-Docs | Formats | Books
      ASIN: B000BBRW7C
      Release Date: 2005-09-07

      Book Description

      This digital document is an article from Air & Space Power Journal, published by Thomson Gale on June 22, 2005. The length of the article is 635 words. The page length shown above is based on a typical 300-word page. The article is delivered in HTML format and is available in your Amazon.com Digital Locker immediately after purchase. You can view it with any web browser.

      Citation Details
      Title: Raid on the Sun: Inside Israel's Secret Campaign That Denied Saddam the Bomb.(Brief Article)(Book Review)
      Author: J. Rick Rosales
      Publication: Air & Space Power Journal (Magazine/Journal)
      Date: June 22, 2005
      Publisher: Thomson Gale
      Volume: 19 Issue: 2 Page: 124(1)

      Article Type: Book Review, Brief Article

      Distributed by Thomson Gale

      Ludwig II of Bavaria: The Swan King
      Average customer rating: 4 out of 5 stars
      • Disappointing Version of a Very INteresting Life
      • A well researched book !
      • Well...
      • Fascinating reading
      • Wonderful
      Ludwig II of Bavaria: The Swan King
      Christopher McIntosh
      Manufacturer: St. Martin's Press
      ProductGroup: Book
      Binding: Paperback

      GeneralGeneral | Biographies & Memoirs | Subjects | Books
      GeneralGeneral | Historical | Biographies & Memoirs | Subjects | Books
      GeneralGeneral | Royalty | Leaders & Notable People | Biographies & Memoirs | Subjects | Books
      GeneralGeneral | World | History | Subjects | Books
      GeneralGeneral | Germany | Europe | History | Subjects | Books
      ASIN: 1860643140

      Customer Reviews:

      2 out of 5 stars Disappointing Version of a Very INteresting Life.......2000-10-12

      THIS VERSION IS DISAPPOINTING. TEDIOUSLY DULL. LUDWIG II WAS ONE OTHE THE MOST COMPLEX AND INTERESTING KINGS OF HIS DAY. THIS BOOK TELLS VERY LITTLE OF THE PERSONAL OR PUBLIC LIFE OF THE KING. YES, HE WAS MAD AS A HATTER, OR SHOULD IT BE CRAZY LIKE A FOX. HE WAS A HARMLESS HOMOSEXUAL THAT LOVED BEAUTY. HE WAS AN ADEQUATE, IF UNINSPIRED KING TO HIS PEOPLE UNTIL THE LAST. IN EARLIER HISTORY, HE WOULD NOT HAVE BEEN TREATED SO BADLY. THIS RENDITION IS MISSING SO MUCH OF THE MAN. IT ISN'T EVEN HALF THE STORY.

      5 out of 5 stars A well researched book !.......2000-05-09

      In March of this year (2000), I was in Bavaria and visited the castles of Ludwig II. Upon my return I purchased this book to learn more about the King. I found this book fascinating. I only wish I had read it before my trip to his castles so I could have appreciated my visit more.

      3 out of 5 stars Well..........2000-04-23

      The problem I find with this book is it focuses on trying to explain rumors by twisting facts into ficton-a problem I found when reading many Evita bios. I feel there definitely needs to be a better bio written for the market. The book on the whole was interesting for me as a first time reader of LudwigII.

      However, the author tends to overlook important issues ie.I was really disappointed when we are told Ludwig toured the western region of Bavaria, but instead of finding out about what he did on the tour(in reflecting his FACTUAL actions),we are drawn back to what Wagner was doing and his importance in Lud's life.

      Good for first time read but I have read better.

      5 out of 5 stars Fascinating reading.......1999-07-07

      A great in-depth look at the life of Ludwig II. McIntosh includes many excerpts from letters and historical documents, and never draws a conclusion without abundant proof to back it up. This book is not just for history buffs--anyone who enjoys a good story should read McIntosh's take on Ludwig's life.

      5 out of 5 stars Wonderful.......1999-06-23

      This book, which was wonderfully researched, provides a detailed information about this magnificent king. It is preferred that persons who read it know a little about the Swan King, but it is not necessary. He discusses Ludwig's intimate life, including controversial topics. One might enjoy this book for many reasons, especially if you have an interest of how court life was around the late 1800's, and how Ludwig's mind worked, his thoughts, feelings, etc. A definate buy!
      The Swan King: Ludwig II of Bavaria
      Average customer rating: 4 out of 5 stars
      • The Swan King: Lugwig II of Bavaria
      The Swan King: Ludwig II of Bavaria
      Christopher McIntosh
      Manufacturer: Tauris Parke Paperbacks
      ProductGroup: Book
      Binding: Paperback

      GeneralGeneral | Biographies & Memoirs | Subjects | Books
      GeneralGeneral | Europe | History | Subjects | Books
      GeneralGeneral | Germany | Europe | History | Subjects | Books
      GeneralGeneral | World | History | Subjects | Books
      Similar Items:
      1. King Ludwig II: Reality And Mystery King Ludwig II: Reality And Mystery
      2. Prost!: The Story of German Beer Prost!: The Story of German Beer
      3. Neuschwanstein  (Opus 33) (Opus) Neuschwanstein (Opus 33) (Opus)
      4. The Mad King: The Life and Times of Ludwig II of Bavaria The Mad King: The Life and Times of Ludwig II of Bavaria
      5. Royalty's Strangest Characters: Extraordinary But True Tales from 2,000 Years of Mad Monarchs and Raving Rulers (Strangest) Royalty's Strangest Characters: Extraordinary But True Tales from 2,000 Years of Mad Monarchs and Raving Rulers (Strangest)

      ASIN: 1860648924

      Book Description

      A revealing and detailed biography of one of the most enigmatic figures of the nineteenth century Refreshingly accessible and thoroughly researched, this biography captures as never before the story of Ludwig II of Bolivia. Ludwig is best remembered for his patronage of Wagner and for the fantasy-like palaces he created. The Swan King presents new conclusions on the more uncertain aspects of Ludwig II's life including his homosexuality, his supposed madness, and the mystery of his death.

      Customer Reviews:

      4 out of 5 stars The Swan King: Lugwig II of Bavaria.......2007-05-25

      The book is a result of extensive research so it's packed with information and, unlike many histories, this one reads like a novel. I not only learned what Ludwig contributed to Bavaria, but felt I knew him as a person.It's a well-written book on a fascinating topic. I plan to go to Munich Germany next year to see Ludwig's castles firsthand. My only complaint about this is with the publisher. The print is so small, older people, over 55, may have a problem reading it.
      LUDWIG II OF BAVARIA: THE SWAN KING
      Average customer rating: Not rated
        LUDWIG II OF BAVARIA: THE SWAN KING
        CHRISTOPHER MCINTOSH
        Manufacturer: I.B. TAURIS
        ProductGroup: Book
        Binding: Paperback
        ASIN: B000S9TO28
        The royal swan: The life and times of King Ludwig II of Bavaria
        Average customer rating: Not rated
          The royal swan: The life and times of King Ludwig II of Bavaria
          Thomas J Price
          Manufacturer: Daring Pub. Group
          ProductGroup: Book
          Binding: Unknown Binding

          GeneralGeneral | Germany | Europe | History | Subjects | Books
          ASIN: 0938936832
          Swan King: Ludwig II of Bavaria.
          Average customer rating: Not rated
            Swan King: Ludwig II of Bavaria.
            Christopher McIntosh
            Manufacturer: see notes for publisher info
            ProductGroup: Book
            Binding: Hardcover
            ASIN: B000M49URS

            High Interest / Low-Readability Action Adventure (High Interest/Low Readability)
            Average customer rating: Not rated
              High Interest / Low-Readability Action Adventure (High Interest/Low Readability)

              Manufacturer: Instructional Fair
              ProductGroup: Book
              Binding: Paperback

              GeneralGeneral | Words & Language | Reference | Subjects | Books
              GeneralGeneral | Science | Subjects | Books
              GeneralGeneral | Mathematics | Science | Subjects | Books
              High SchoolHigh School | Education | Nonfiction | Subjects | Books
              GeneralGeneral | Ages 9-12 | Children's Books | Subjects | Books
              High SchoolHigh School | By Level | Education | Professional & Technical | Subjects | Books
              Similar Items:
              1. High Interest / Low-Readability Non-fiction, Volume I (High Interest/Low Readability) High Interest / Low-Readability Non-fiction, Volume I (High Interest/Low Readability)
              2. High Interest / Low-Readability Mysteries, Grade 6 (High Interest/Low Readability) High Interest / Low-Readability Mysteries, Grade 6 (High Interest/Low Readability)

              ASIN: 0769633927

              Book Description

              Action Adventure is a book of short stories designed to attract the attention and interest of students who are reading below grade level. Low reading levels are achieved through the use of controlled vocabulary, simple sentence structure, and clear graphic design. Interesting plots, realism, and relevance are the principal elements of these stories.

              The questions and student activity sheets are designed to improve the reading comprehension skills of remedial readers. The stories and activities can be used as part of a teacher-directed lesson or assigned as independent work.

              The Western Range Revisited: Removing Livestock from Public Lands to Conserve Native Biodiversity (Legal History of North America Series, Vol 5)
              Average customer rating: 4 out of 5 stars
              • Public Land Grazing nearly Killed Me
              • Terrible book
              • Missed some major points
              • Look closer
              • Rachel Carson Redux
              The Western Range Revisited: Removing Livestock from Public Lands to Conserve Native Biodiversity (Legal History of North America Series, Vol 5)
              Debra L. Donahue
              Manufacturer: University of Oklahoma Press
              ProductGroup: Book
              Binding: Paperback

              GeneralGeneral | Popular Economics | Business & Investing | Subjects | Books
              AmericasAmericas | History | Subjects | Books | Canada | Caribbean & West Indies | Central America | General | Greenland | Mexico | Native American | South America | United States
              Environmental & Natural Resources LawEnvironmental & Natural Resources Law | Law | Subjects | Books
              GeneralGeneral | Law | Subjects | Books
              WildlifeWildlife | Animals | Biological Sciences | Science | Subjects | Books
              Environmental ScienceEnvironmental Science | Earth Sciences | Science | Subjects | Books
              ConservationConservation | Environment | Outdoors & Nature | Subjects | Books
              Environmental ScienceEnvironmental Science | Earth Sciences | Professional Science | Professional & Technical | Subjects | Books
              Environmental & Natural Resources LawEnvironmental & Natural Resources Law | Law | Professional & Technical | Subjects | Books
              Similar Items:
              1. Justice and Natural Resources: Concepts, Strategies, and Applications Justice and Natural Resources: Concepts, Strategies, and Applications
              2. Sacred Cows at the Public Trough Sacred Cows at the Public Trough
              3. Palgrave Advances in International Environmental Politics (Palgrave Advances) Palgrave Advances in International Environmental Politics (Palgrave Advances)
              4. Crossing the Next Meridian: Land, Water, and the Future of the West Crossing the Next Meridian: Land, Water, and the Future of the West
              5. Green Planet Blues: Environmental Politics from Stockholm to Johannesburg Green Planet Blues: Environmental Politics from Stockholm to Johannesburg

              ASIN: 0806132981

              Amazon.com

              What happens when you dare talk about evicting cows from the West? If you're professor Debra Donahue, a considerably nonplussed Wyoming state senator threatens to introduce legislation to dissolve your employer, the University of Wyoming law school. While Senator Jim Twiford's threat can be viewed as a stunt, there's no denying that Donahue and her book The Western Range Revisited have upset the status quo in this arid state with a population less than that of Salt Lake City. Specifically, Donahue recommends livestock be removed from public lands "receiving 12 inches of precipitation or less annually." To support this argument, she examines a bumper crop of scientific evidence pointing to "severe degradation of western ranges" caused by overgrazing--and, in the process, unravels a complex tangle of regional politics and culture that foster such overgrazing. Why, for instance, does the livestock industry enjoy such political clout when it employs so few people? One reason, explains Donahue, is that the relatively unpopulous intermountain West "accounts for approximately one-third of the total Senate membership; thus westerners generally wield disproportionate influence on the Senate." Resulting from this influence, says Donahue, are two fallacies that conspire to keep livestock on the range despite poor return on investment and egregious environmental damage: "Public land grazing is important to the economic base of local communities, if not the region, and the ranching way of life merits preservation, both for its own sake and as a means of preserving the West's open spaces."

              Cowboys take their lumps, too, from the author's cultural demythologizing: to wit, the so-called rugged individualists of Catron County, New Mexico--a hotbed of antigovernment fervor--collect more federal subsidies than the national average. Why? Because they're trying to live off public land that has been abused for more than a century.

              Donahue concludes that grazing's "ecological impacts are more widespread than those of any other human activity in the West, and elimination of grazing holds greater potential for benefiting biodiversity than any other single land use measure." That said, the "essential ingredient yet lacking is the political will to oppose a narrow, but powerful, interest group--the deeply entrenched western livestock industry." Whether or not you agree with Donahue's thesis, her controversial book will go a long way toward bringing this debate to a broader audience. --Langdon Cook

              Book Description

              Livestock grazing is the most widespread commercial use of federal public lands. The image of a herd grazing on Bureau of Land Management or U.S. Forest Service lands is so traditional that many view this use as central to the history and culture of the West. Yet the grazing program costs far more to administer than it generates in revenues, and grazing affects all other uses of public lands, causing potentially irreversible damage to native wildlife and vegetation.

              THE WESTERN RANGE REVISITED proposes a landscape-level strategy for conserving native biological diversity on federal rangelands, a strategy based chiefly on removing livestock from large tracts of arid BLM lands in ten western states: Arizona, California, Colorado, Idaho, Nevada, New Mexico, Oregon, Utah, Washington, Wyoming.

              Drawing from range ecology, conservation biology, law, and economics, Debra L. Donahue examines the history of federal grazing policy and the current debate on federal multiple-use, sustained-yield policies and changing priorities for our public lands. Donahue, a lawyer and wildlife biologist, uses existing laws and regulations, historical documents, economic statistics, and current scientific thinking to make a strong case for a land-management strategy that has been, until now, "unthinkable."

              A groundbreaking interdisciplinary work, THE WESTERN RANGE REVISITED demonstrates that conserving biodiversity by eliminating or reducing livestock grazing makes economic sense, is ecologically expedient, and can be achieved under current law.

              Customer Reviews:

              5 out of 5 stars Public Land Grazing nearly Killed Me.......2003-04-20

              After reading Debra Donahue's powerful book on the misuse and abuse of western grazing lands, I'm of the opinion that she might be as well remembered in the future as Rachel Carson is today. She has vividly pointed to a problem that has broad negative implications for everyone in the U.S. today.

              Permit me to briefly tell you my story with respect to open range grazing.

              While vacationing at my in-laws in Arizona in 1997, I went down to the San Pedro River with my daughter and some nephews. While the kids played in the water, I sat in the water watching - scratching some bug bites that I'd received the previous day. After several hours, I took a walk upstream about 100 yards, and discovered the body of a dead "open range" cow lying in the river.

              Five days later, back in California, I awoke to a raging fever with rashes up both legs and a left thumb triple its normal size. After rushing to the hospital and beginning emergency antibiotic treatment, I was diagnosed with an infection by "flesh eating bacteria".

              Let their be no doubt, my exposure to a antibiotic-doped-up range cow dead in the San Pedro River was the cause of my ailment.

              After five days and 39 pints of antibiotics, I went home with a thumb joint that is fused and unusable. If not for the presently effective antibiotics still available to humans, I would have had my left hand amputated.

              Debra's book touches upon the ecological destruction that is done on Western grazing lands for the sake of partially producting 3% of the U.S. beef production. (All these cows must be sent to a feed lot to be fed adequately for butchering.) You must read this book and you must act upon it -- it's for all our sake.

              1 out of 5 stars Terrible book.......2001-12-12

              This book is simply a polemic to eliminate livestock from the rangelands of the US and has no objective basis in fact. It has no merit whatsoever except as a guide to the limits to which anti-large mammal fanatics will go. I would have given it zero stars, but that is not one of the alternatives.

              1 out of 5 stars Missed some major points.......2001-02-21

              Debra Donahue lays out lots of stats but misses the key facts about the ownership of the "public lands" of the west. If you are looking for a book that says cattle are bad, this is it. If you are looking for some facts to broaden your knowledge of the west or the land, this is not it.

              2 out of 5 stars Look closer.......2001-01-25

              Debra Donahue is a University of Wyoming law professor with a background in range and wildlife biology. She is motivated by a striking concern for the Western landscape. In The Western Range Revisited, Donahue makes a factual, thoughtful, but unconvincing case for ending livestock grazing on public lands. After laying an impressive foundation, Donahue stumbles badly in Chapter 8 - "The Socio-Economic Landscape." She states the two main arguments against her thesis: "Public land grazing is important to the economic base of the local community, if not the region, and the ranching way of life merits preservation both for its own sake and as a means of preserving the West's open spaces (p 229)." If we do away with these arguments, "no warrant should remain for leaving livestock on arid public lands (ibid)." She fails to do so. Many statistics are used but not fully explored. Only 2% of all livestock are produced by federal lease lands. Perhaps, but what of the local economies? About 70% of ranchers do not rely on federal leases (p 253). But what of the 30% who do? Large operations (those running 151 Animal Units or more) generate 75% or more of their income from cows; small operations (150 Animal Units or less) generate only 39% of their income from stock .(p 240). Donahue states that 300 units is a break-even operation - yet argues at the same time that eliminating leases would matter little since ranchers could, 1) intensify use of their private lands, or, 2) reduce herd size. Intensification of private lands would create severe overgrazing, water pollution from runoff, and destroy wildlife habitat (since 75% of the big game winter range alone is found on private lands in the Rockies). Reducing herd size would drop more ranches below her own definition of "breaking even" which would lead ultimately to subdivision and development. Ranching is already economically tenuous - "only a 1-3% return on capital investment" (p 260). Donahue wants to make it worse. We cannot argue away geographic certainties with a dither of statistics. I have worked with The Nature Conservancy, the Montana Land Reliance, and other trusts for 24 years. I have done biological inventories on scores of ranches and designed nearly 100 conservation easements. A profound, simple fact has emerged - overall, ranchers do a good job as land stewards on both land they own and land they lease. If they did not, why do so many ranches meet the qualification criteria of groups formed to protect biological diversity? I have designed conservation easements on ranches that protect wolves, grizzly bears, black-footed ferrets, bald eagles, and an array of endemic non-game organisms ranging from a rare rockcress to a globally endangered freshwater sponge. Many ranchers are conservationists and to make sweeping condemnations is insulting and plain silly. Donahue does not understand ranchers and makes little attempt to. The two major books on ranching culture were missing from her bibliography: Paul Starrs' Let the Cowboy Ride: Cattle Ranching in the American West (1998) and Terry Jordan's North American Cattle Ranching Frontiers (1993). The author also does not understand land regulation and conservation, making mis-statements about conservation easements and land trusts, and falling back on ineffective, politically untenable tools such as zoning as a way to stop development. None of the literature on these critical subjects was used (see, for example: Saving American Farmland: What Works by the American Farmland Trust, 1997). That is a glaring omission given the stakes here. Debra Donahue reached too far with The Western Range Revisited. She argues that ranching is much like mining and logging - an environmentally destructive, economically misguided use of public lands (see, The Economic Pursuit of Quality by Thomas Power, 1988). In fact, the landscape ecology of ranches is much different - they serve as habitat corridors for species movement and as buffers between development and wild lands. If Donahue had persuaded us of the need to revise or eliminate riparian grazing, increase protection for Heritage caliber biota, and revoke the permits of poor livestock managers, this book would have made a valuable contribution. Instead, she chose to attack and alienate an entire group of people who are worthy of being understood and respected. The Western culture wars continue. John B. Wright, Department of Geography, New Mexico State University

              5 out of 5 stars Rachel Carson Redux.......2000-11-30

              After reading Debra Donahue's powerful book on the misuse and abuse of western grazing lands, I'm of the opinion that she might be as well remebered in the future as Rachel Carson is today. She has vividly pointed to a problem that has broad negative implications on everyone living in the U.S. today.

              Permit me to briefly tell you my story with respect to open range grazing.

              While vacationing at my in-laws in Arizona in 1997, I went down to the San Pedro River with my daughter and some nephews. While the kids played in the water, I sat in the water watching - scratching some bug bites that I'd received the previous day. After several hours, I took a walk upstream about 100 yards, and discovered the body of a dead "open range" cow lying in the river.

              Five days later, back in California, I awoke to a ranging fever with rashes up both legs and a left thumb triple its normal size. After rushing to the hospital and beginning emergency antibiotic treatment, I was diagnosed with "flesh eating bacteria".

              Let their be no doubt, my exposure to a antibiotic-doped-up range cow dead in the San Pedro River was the cause of my ailment.

              After five days and 39 pints of antibiotics, I went home with a thumb joint that is fused and unusable. If not for modern antibiotics, I would have had my left hand amputated.

              Debra's book touches upon the ecological destruction that is done on Western grazing lands for the sake of partially producting 3% of the U.S. beef production. (All these cows must be sent to a feed lot to be fed adequately for butchering.) You must read this book and you must act upon it -- it's for all our sake.

              Books:

              1. REAL Ultimate Power: The Official Ninja Book
              2. Rescue At The Top Of The World
              3. Saipan & Tinian 1944: Piercing the Japanese Empire (Campaign)
              4. Shadow Wars: Special Forces in the New Battle Against Terrorism
              5. Sherman Medium Tank 1942-45 (New Vanguard)
              6. Shiloh--In Hell Before Night
              7. Shiloh: The Battle That Changed the Civil War
              8. Slacks and Calluses: Our Summer in a Bomber Factory
              9. Strategy: The Logic of War and Peace, Revised and Enlarged Edition
              10. The Battle for Guatemala: Rebels, Death Squads, and U.S. Power (Latin American Perspectives Series)

              Books Index

              Books Home

              Recommended Books

              1. Life and Campaigns of Stonewall Jackson
              2. History: Fiction or Science
              3. Death in the Andes
              4. Dancing with Your Dark Horse: How Horse Sense Helps Us Find Balance, Strength and Wisdom
              5. David Gets in Trouble
              6. History: Fiction or Science
              7. Fundamentals of Anatomy & Physiology
              8. The Vision: The Dramatic True Story of One Man's Search for Enlightenment
              9. Eleanor of Provence: Queenship in the Thirteenth-Century England
              10. Rocky Mountain Wildflowers: Photos, Descriptions, and Early Explorer Insights