Book Description
Now in paperback, Selling the Holocaust includes a new introduction by the author which includes an analysis of Life is Beautiful and Peter Novick's Holocaust in American Life
Customer Reviews:
outstanding.......2007-10-07
An important work. It really takes a fascinating, unique perspective on history and provides a provocative view on the true nature of many people's fascination with the Holocaust.
The Gradual Development of the Holocaust "Myth".......2006-08-12
Cole traces the development of popularization of the Holocaust in the US, Israel, and in other parts of the world. He uses the term "myth" not to question the fact of 5-6 million murdered Jews in any way, but to point out the gradual emergence of the Holocaust in much contemporary thinking. Cole (p. 6) quotes Yaffa Eliach on the fact that "there is no business like Shoah business."
In common with other writers (e. g., Novick, Finkelstein), Cole points out that there was little special attention paid to the WWII extermination of Jews, by either Jews or gentiles, in the first years after the war: "While the Holocaust was perpetrated in Europe during 1941-45, it was not really until the early 1960s that anything like widespread awareness of the `Holocaust' began to emerge."(p. 7). Also: "During the 1940s and 1950s, throughout Israeli society, there was an effective silence about the Holocaust."(pp. 51-52). Finally, "After 1961 the Holocaust ceased to be a taboo, and instead assumed an increasingly central--if contested--position in Israeli society and politics."(p. 63).
Cole concludes: "There is little question that in the 1970s and 1980s the `Holocaust' assumed a critical role in self-definition as Jewish." (p. 13). In fact, he also shows that the Holocaust had become a substitute for Jewish tradition, for self-identity as Jews, among many assimilated American Jews (pp. 118-119).
By the 1990's, the Holocaust had assumed nothing short of staggering dimensions on the American scene: "...in the United States there are more than one hundred Holocaust museums and research centres, suggesting that the `founding of Holocaust museums' is `a particularly American phenomenon.'"(p. 147).
Cole devotes a moderate amount of attention to the Auschwitz Carmelite convent controversy. For a long time, Christian symbols in Jewish places of death had not aroused Jewish antagonism at all (p. 103). He also points out the fact that, ironically, Auschwitz itself had assumed a prominent place in Jewish Holocaust consciousness only gradually: "From being a site of Warsaw bloc memory of fascist atrocity, `Auschwitz' became recognized not simply as a site of the mass gassing of Jews, but the site of Jewish memory of the `Holocaust'. Yet alongside this `Jewish Holocaustisation' of Auschwitz, a process of `Catholising' Auschwitz started to take place, in particular centered on the Polish-Catholic martyr Father Maximilian Kolbe."(pp. 102-103). Cole continues: "What was being contested during the controversy was less ownership and use of the physical fabric of the camp, and more ownership and use of the `brandname''Auschwitz'."(p. 105).
Cole (p. 108) then recounts Cardinal Glemp's suggested compromise solution: Oswiecim-Auschwitz, where mostly Poles died, would be central to Poles and Christians, while Brzezinka-Birkenau, where mostly Jews died, would be central to Jews. However, most Jews rejected this compromise solution on the grounds that it would impinge upon the symbolic status of Auschwitz. What is unclear in all of this is how the fact that 90% of the victims of the entire Auschwitz complex were Jews is supposed to entitle them to dictate to everyone else how and how not the site of the Auschwitz complex is to be memorialized. It is easy to see that all the talk about the Jewish victims of Auschwitz being forgotten, or about Auschwitz becoming "Christianized", are simply smokescreens. The real reason clearly is Jewish intolerance against the sufferings of non-Jews being associated, even indirectly, with the sufferings of Jews. As further proof of this, note Cole's citation of Israeli philosopher Adi Ophir on the latter's statements concerning the Holocaust becoming a religion of sorts that supplants the Ten Commandments: "...Holocaust religion offers new commandments:'Thou shalt have no other Holocaust', `Thou shalt not make unto thee any graven image or likeness", Thou shalt not take the name in vain'. .."(p. 143). No wonder that there was so much Jewish opposition to the Carmelite convent at Auschwitz! Its very presence dared juxtapose the Polish Holocaust with that the Jewish Holocaust, thereby violating the first and third of these new commandments!
Cole describes Holocaust education in contemporary Israel as follows: "Not only do they have `Holocaust' lessons at school--where `since the early 1980s, questions on the Holocaust have accounted for 20 per cent of the overall score in the high school diploma examination in history'--but as mentioned earlier they all visit Yad Vashem, and an increasing number visit the death camps in Europe."(p. 141). In view of this intense education, the ignorance of Israeli students who visit Poland is unbelievable (unless, of course, it is intentional). Cole does not mention the fact that visiting Israeli students hold to grotesque Polonophobic errors, even to the point of believing that Poles killed more Jews than the Germans, and asking, in all seriousness, about the size of pensions "those Polish guards at Auschwitz" are receiving. What kind of education are these young Israelis truly getting?
Man's Search for Meaning?.......2006-05-24
I appreciated Cole's ability to trace the evolution of Holocaust representation over the years and his comparison of how different cultures portray it. I also agree that the media generally fails to convey the desperation and hopelessness inherent in The Holocaust. The Holocaust should not be remembered only as an inspiring story of courage and survival- we must remember the terror, despair, hopelessness, and depravity.
Maybe the public consumers are not interested or prepared for the graphic details or a protagonist whose death seems as meaningless as it is vicious. Perhaps the public consumers are not ready for a Nazi protagonist who has more in common with the reader/viewer than his victim. If Holocaust literature and media are not able to break this barrior, the meaning of this tragedy will indeed be lost.
However, I am disappointed in Cole's criticism of U.S., Israeli, and European efforts to make meaning of The Holocaust. Is it surprising, or even wrong, that an Israeli museum/memorial would emphasize Jewish resistance and heroism during The Holocaust? Is it surprising that the U.S. museum would focus on Jews as victims and American soldiers as liberators?
While everyone must be careful in how they portray and memorialize The Holocaust, the search for meaning must be a part of such an endeavor. One must explore why the Nazis acted as they did. One must consider why many Jews did not resist and some even betrayed those who did. One must acknowledge the courage of Jews who resisted and Allied soldiers who liberated the camps.
I encourage anyone who reads this book to also read Viktor Frankl's MAN'S SEARCH FOR MEANING.
Disappointing, frustrating, and poorly titled and marketed.......2006-04-16
I approached this book w reasonably high expectations.
i thank tim cole for the effort and i got some value out of this book
But I found the book to be weakly argued and inconsistent.
I felt a bit ripped off by the title, the book jacket and the back blurb by michael lerner, whom i respect.
the book was really about the evolving ways that israel and the US (and to a lesser extent europe) interpret the holocaust through the decades, as driven by their own new national needs and circumstances.
so -- we are not mostly talking in this book so much about 'sale' and exploitation (as implied by the title and book jacket description, which focuses highly on $$$) of the holocaust...
...but rather about evolving interpretations as 'recallers' change their perspectives as new societal needs arise -- and they change their interpretive thrusts of the holocaust to meet changing contemporary needs
thus, for me, the title didnt match the book.
i was especially frustrated by the author's repeated expressed longing for holocaust museums to focus more heavily on the magnitude and terribleness unfathomability of the killing - and the massive despair grimness and unknowabiliity of the act -- and not just to look for 'redemptive' or 'heroic' twists on the event. he is unhappy that museum builders focus too heavily on the holocaust's 'redemptive' value, and ok, he makes that point well enough
and then he talks about he and his wife visiting a holocaust museum and coming away disappointed because there was not enough 'horror.'
but then when horror IS displayed in a museum, he seems critical and dismissive, and seems to ridicule it. it is odd how his seeming desires seem unfulfillable. after reading this book, while seeking to keep an open mind, i can't imagine a holocaust museum that would ever satisfy tim cole.
cole also harps annoyingly on a single sentence at yad vashem (his 'although-also' sentence/cite) and repeats it about ten times afterwards. he builds way too much out of this single sentence, even understanding the single sentence is meant to be emblematic of an attitude. but he endows it with too much meaning -- and that sentence just cant keep sustaining the weight of his thesis again and again and again. seems like a weak and imbalanced argument from an academic.
the lerner blurb is a big sore point. it says the book points to the need to take action to prevent another holocaust (he cites the pressing need to "transform the conditions that make equally horrible suffering a likely recurrence."). but to my great chagrin, nowhere at all in the book does cole spend any time offering this kind of advice. or i missed it but i dont think i did. very disappointing. i felt misled by the lerner quote and misled by the jacket blurb. the lerner quote does not gibe w the book content, and i am sadly left to ask whether lerner had actually read the book first (i deeply hope so)
the thrust of the book's content is worthwhile: that history can often be bent to the evolving needs of succeeding generations. fair enough, and a good point for us all to remember. this precise same point is directly discussed, for example, in 'these honored dead,' tom desjardin's take on the manipulation of gettysburg history.
but i assert that that isnt really a book about 'selling' history. it is more substantially about 'reinterpreting' history.
so i was disappointed, annoyed and frustrated by the book. it had some good content and some eye-opening analysis, and from time to time, he makes his point fairly well.
but its title and marketing message were a tease that didnt accurately reflect its content.
the book is called 'the selling of...' yet the content spends little time focused on the 'selling.'
i hope i am wrong, but i felt maybe a publisher told tim cole that he better give it this particular title so more people like me would read it and more people would buy it.
...which leads me to an unhappy conclusion:
i feel i have been a little exploited by 'the selling of...' this book to me.
Disappointing........2005-02-12
Having read and seen more than my fair share of Holocaust-related books and films, I was hoping for some provocative, or at least thought-provoking, analysis here. Instead, I was treated to a superficial and incomplete overview. From start to finish, Cole's contention is that in literary and cinematographic works the Holocaust has been packaged to supply consumers with a "happy ending", and that in endeavours such as museums the full horror is deliberately (although the reader is left in some doubt as to how consciously) blanked out or softened.
In fact, many survivors have pointed out that the full horror can never be known, as even their own experience could only be partial. Another fact is that all the first-hand accounts, however gruesome, have been given by survivors, which does tend to leave an impression of the Holocaust as something which could be (and in fact was) survived, if only by a minority. It is a pity that Cole did not take a closer look at the abundant literature describing the damage wreaked on survivors and their families, for instance Art Spiegelman's depiction of his parents, Lily Brett's of her mother, or Charlotte Delbo's wrenching account of the individual lives of her fellow deportees before, during and after their imprisonment in Auschwitz.
There are also occurrences of sloppy thinking. For instance, Cole has accomplished the tour de force of simultaneously criticising the early presentation of Anne Frank for "stripping her of her sexuality" and drawing a veil over her appalling death. Actually, that early presentation was almost exclusively based on the first published version of the Diary, which made no secret of Anne's romance with Peter (sexual enough to cause her parents serious concern), and surely it is not common for diarists to record their own demise, least of all in a death camp?
Finally, there are a number of careless errors not acceptable in a scholarly work. The recurrent misspelling of "Birkeneau" is especially irritating in view of Cole's credentials, "the girl in the red coat" of "Schindler's List", whom Cole dismisses as a "myth" incorporated by Spielberg into his film, does in fact appear in Keneally's book under the name "Red Genia", and the Jews in the "Train of Life" do not escape to freedom - the last scene shows the narrator in prisoner's garb, possibly German, possibly Soviet, behind barbed wire, leaving it unclear whether the train story was a fantasy or whether the Gulag ultimately caught up with the escaped Jews.
In a word, disappointing.
Book Description
This digital document is an article from American Jewish History, published by American Jewish Historical Society on March 1, 2000. The length of the article is 2352 words. The page length shown above is based on a typical 300-word page. The article is delivered in HTML format and is available in your Amazon.com Digital Locker immediately after purchase. You can view it with any web browser.
Citation Details
Title: Selling the Holocaust: From Auschwitz to Schindler, How History is Bought, Packaged, and Sold.(Review) (book review)
Publication:
American Jewish History (Refereed)
Date: March 1, 2000
Publisher: American Jewish Historical Society
Volume: 88
Issue: 1
Page: 127
Article Type: Book Review
Distributed by Thomson Gale
Average customer rating:
|
Sociability and Power in Late-Stuart England: The Cultural Worlds of the Verneys 1660-1720
Susan E. Whyman
Manufacturer: Oxford University Press, USA
ProductGroup: Book
Binding: Paperback
 General
| United States
| Americas
| History
| Subjects
| Books
General
| Europe
| History
| Subjects
| Books
General
| England
| Europe
| History
| Subjects
| Books
Tudor & Stuart
| England
| Europe
| History
| Subjects
| Books
General
| Ireland
| Europe
| History
| Subjects
| Books
General
| World
| History
| Subjects
| Books
17th Century
| World
| History
| Subjects
| Books
Social History
| Historical Study
| History
| Subjects
| Books
Social Work
| Social Sciences
| Nonfiction
| Subjects
| Books
Culture
| Sociology
| Social Sciences
| Nonfiction
| Subjects
| Books
All Titles
| Qualifying Textbooks - Fall 2007
| Stores
| Books
ASIN: 0199250235 |
Book Description
This highly original study looks at rituals of sociability in new and creative ways. Based upon thousands of personal letters, it reconstructs the changing country and London worlds of an English gentry family, and reveals intimate details about the social and cultural life of the period. Challenging current influential views, the book observes strong connections, instead of deep divisions, between country and city, land and trade, sociability and power. Its very different view undermines established stereotypes of omnipotent male patriarchs, powerless wives and kin, autonomous elder sons, and dependent younger brothers. Gifts of venison and visits in a coach reveal unexpected findings about the subtle power of women over the social code, the importance of younger sons, and the overwhelming impact of London. Successfully combining storytelling and historical analysis, the book recreates everyday lives in a period of overseas expansion, financial revolution, and political turmoil.
Book Description
R. Buckminster Fuller's Operating Manual for Spaceship Earth, published in 1969, imagines our species as a crew, united by a shared fate, on a tiny spaceship traveling through infinity. It can be read even today as the most intelligent metaphor for thinking about humankind on this planet. Fuller accepted the challenge pre-sented by this metaphor, using his inventions and writings to contribute to the safe operations of Spaceship Earth.
This title is an exact facsimile of the 1969 edition.
Customer Reviews:
readable bucky.......2005-11-03
This is the clearest I've ever known this man to be. This concise volume gets to the heart of our wordly matters. Elegant, comprehensive, his soul speaks in all of his writings, and this condensed version is very good for the first time Bucky reader. I suggest it highly to anyone who wants to learn a lot in a little time.
Control, Operate and Plan Your Spaceship.......2000-03-11
R. Buckminster Fuller's (Bucky hereout), designer of the geodesic dome (one can see at EPCOT), lays down the thought patterns of a successful world in this short and concise book based on his discoveries (probably more appropriate than inventions, as he said "I am not tryingto imitate nature, I'm trying to find the principles she uses"). It is in this book that Bucky gives the reader insight into how he thinks, and how to change ones thinking entirely, to see the Earth as a Spaceship. To feel yourself riding the Earth as a Spaceship. Demonstrating from the anceint "pirates" and how evolution is changed through specialization. How a wealthy nation, such as ours, cannot afford to make economical mishaps or delays on such life-giving elements as water. Moving our modes of consciousness into Einsteinian, omni-directional thinking, we can then turn to everyone to "co-operate." To help others, and not gain at the expense of others. Certainly a classic in its own right, this book will change the way you think, not about life or the world, just that you change your thinking, making every action a universal consequence. There is only one Earth, and we are all living in it. Reccomended!
You need to read this book!.......1999-04-01
I really mean it. This book makes much more sense than any government plan that I know of. We all need to read this book.
Must reading for todays 30 something generation........1998-08-24
Our forefathers, parents and their peers have delivered us a drastically (wonderfully) complex society with ever increasing difficulties, and opportunities. RBF does an uncommonly fine job of explaining some of the underlying drives that brought us here. Maybe also sheds light on a usefull path to the future.
A primer for Bucky's followers.......1997-07-31
If you have any interest in R. Buckminster Fuller's philosophies, inventions and thoughts, this book is a good starting point. Other of his works can be more difficult to absorb, easily. Fuller's basic concepts of "synergy," "ephemeralization" and "modern day pirates" are all made clear here. If you read this short work and are intrigued by the man and the distinctions he brought to the world, you can proceed from here.
Sorry OMSE is getting difficult to find. Now that Bucky's "phantom Captain" has moved on, his words are what we have to instruct us -- these, and the wonderful contributions of Bucky's students to the "world game."
Average customer rating:
- A good history of Yosemite written for elitist backpackers
- NPS needs to learn a science lesson
|
Yosemite: The Embattled Wilderness
Alfred Runte
Manufacturer: University of Nebraska Press
ProductGroup: Book
Binding: Paperback
General
| United States
| Americas
| History
| Subjects
| Books
California
| State & Local
| United States
| Americas
| History
| Subjects
| Books
Environmental Science
| Earth Sciences
| Science
| Subjects
| Books
Natural History
| Nature & Ecology
| Science
| Subjects
| Books
Parks & Campgrounds
| Food & Lodging
| Reference & Tips
| Travel
| Subjects
| Books
Ecotourism
| Specialty Travel
| Travel
| Subjects
| Books
Travel with Pets
| Specialty Travel
| Travel
| Subjects
| Books
General
| California
| States
| United States
| Travel
| Subjects
| Books
Yosemite
| California
| States
| United States
| Travel
| Subjects
| Books
North America
| Travel
| Subjects
| Books
General
| Travel
| Subjects
| Books
Environmental Science
| Earth Sciences
| Professional Science
| Professional & Technical
| Subjects
| Books
General
| Conservation
| Outdoors & Nature
| Subjects
| Books
General
| Urban Planning & Development
| Nonfiction
| Subjects
| Books
Similar Items:
-
Yosemite and Sequoia: A Century of California National Parks
ASIN: 0803289413 |
Customer Reviews:
A good history of Yosemite written for elitist backpackers.......2006-02-25
This book provides a history of Yosemite National Park with a particular focus - Runte's ongoing complaints about activities in the park that can be done elsewhere. These would include `resort" activities in Yosemite Valley such as swimming pools or bike and raft rentals, skiing at Badger Pass, or golfing at Wawona. He takes a strongly preservationist position, and emphasizes protection of wildlife.
I'm sympathetic to all those positions but in Runte's hands it all comes across as elitist. Unlike Joseph Sax's "Mountains without Handrails," Runte does not try to make the principled argument about why camping is good while swimming pools are bad; instead, he simply asserts this repeatedly.
This material in his narrative is valuable, and you'll learn a lot about this park even if you already know quite a bit. If you like your RV, this book will annoy you; if you're a backpacker, you'll agree with most of his complaints. The overall argument would have been more persuasive if he'd provided a stronger foundation for his value judgments.
NPS needs to learn a science lesson.......2004-12-02
Alfred Runte, a renowned environmental historian, argues in this volume that no other national park more dramatically reflects the United States' alleged failures to reconcile nature protection with the demands of a visiting public. The volume does not trace the entire history of Yosemite National Park, but instead focuses on the environmental aspects of the park's history. The book, gratefully, does not repeat familiar themes like the Hetch Hetchy Dam controversy. The author notes in the introduction that he wants to break new ground.
Yosemite, being the first land set aside for preservation by the U.S. government, has become the longest-running evidence of the tension between preservation and use and the symbol of the National Park idea at its finest and worst (7). One of its less-than-stellar moments came in 1868, only four years after its designation, when the House of Representatives passed legislation that would have given two Yosemite Valley squatters clear title two their land claims. Luckily, the bill did not carry in the Senate and the park was spared a move that would have greatly undermined the original Yosemite grant. In this presentation of early park history, Runte retreads territory established in his previous volume, National Parks: The American Experience, arguing that Yosemite is the real birthplace of the national park idea because it had been established, publicized, challenged and upheld before Congress designated Yellowstone in 1872.
Much of the volume discusses in detail how the major foundation of the national park experiment is a contradiction. For example, individuals, such as the 1868 Yosemite squatters, could profit by promoting development in parks; they simply could not acquire the attractions themselves (27). The presence of development in Yosemite Valley, in effect, broadcast that no natural resource was distinctive enough to merit unswerving protection (219). Runte's narrative argues that the doctrine of visitor accommodation is too firmly entrenched in park management. Administration of natural resources, which has always taken a backseat to tourism, has been reformed in Yosemite usually only after heavy public outcry or scandal. The author makes a compelling case that the NPS, throughout its history, has shown it is too prone to making quick, emotional decisions instead of educated decisions made on the basis of sound scientific research.
Runte presents problems of park service management and also offers a few possible solutions. He advocates public transportation in national parks, something that Yosemite management instituted in the Eastern third of Yosemite Valley in the 1970s because of traffic gridlock and lack of adequate parking space and what Zion National Park embraced in 2000 to control congestion in its most popular stretch of road, Zion Canyon. He also encourages non-profit foundations taking over park concessions, arguing that such a move would be more compatible with preservation, education and cooperation (223).
Runte's narrative, while insightful, is somewhat dated. A second edition would be a welcome addition to a story that uses Yosemite as a lens to show the bigger picture, that NPS management needs to encourage scientifically based resource management to ensure the national parks are preserved for the enjoyment of posterity.
Average customer rating:
|
YOSEMITE: THE EMBATTLED WILDERNESS.
Alfred. Runte
Manufacturer: Lincoln, Nebraska U.P., 1990. 271 pp., illus. in color and b/w. Fine copy of first edition in dust jacket.
ProductGroup: Book
Binding: Hardcover
ASIN: B000UDWVFE |
Books:
- Slavery and Rebellion in the Roman World, 140 B.C.-70 B.C.
- Spy Book: The Encyclopedia of Espionage
- Struggle for the Round Tops: Law's Alabama Brigade at the Battle of Gettysburg, July 2-3, 1863
- Tales of the Congaree
- Texas Connection With the American Revolution
- The Cambridge Dictionary of Classical Civilization
- The Columbia Guide to African American History Since 1939 (Columbia Guides to American History and Cultures)
- The Confederacy: Selections from the Four-Volume Macmillan Encyclopedia of the Confederacy (Macmillan Compendium)
- The East-West Quartet
- The Enlightenment: An Historical Introduction (The Making of Europe)
Books Index
Books Home
Recommended Books
- Teacher Man: A Memoir
- Liber Chaotica Complete: Being an account of the dark secrets and arcane law of the most terible mys
- In the Province of Saints: A Novel
- In a Blaze of Glory: Womanist Spirituality As Social Witness
- History: Fiction or Science
- Introduction to Solid State Physics
- Nazi Millionaires: The Allied Search for Hidden SS Gold
- Victoria Calling Cards: Business and Calling Card Design
- Kevyn Aucoin a beautiful life: The Success, Struggles, and Beauty Secrets of a Legendary Makeup Arti
- The structure and reproduction of members of the Rhodymeniaceae
Lovely Green Eyes
The Holocaust in American Life
The War Against the Jews: 1933-1945
Popular Culture and the Shaping of Holocaust Memory in America (Samuel and Althea Stroum Lectures in Jewish Studies)
The Americanization of the Holocaust
