Mao: The Unknown Story
Average customer rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars
  • Evil Mao
  • what a joke!
  • The Black Book...and the Red one...
  • Caveats, but well worth the price of admission
  • Very disapointing
Mao: The Unknown Story
Jung Chang , and Jon Halliday
Manufacturer: Anchor
ProductGroup: Book
Binding: Paperback

GeneralGeneral | Biographies & Memoirs | Subjects | Books
GeneralGeneral | Historical | Biographies & Memoirs | Subjects | Books
PoliticalPolitical | Leaders & Notable People | Biographies & Memoirs | Subjects | Books
GeneralGeneral | China | Asia | History | Subjects | Books
Similar Items:
  1. Wild Swans : Three Daughters of China Wild Swans : Three Daughters of China
  2. Team of Rivals Team of Rivals
  3. A War Like No Other: How the Athenians and Spartans Fought the Peloponnesian War A War Like No Other: How the Athenians and Spartans Fought the Peloponnesian War
  4. Postwar : A History of Europe Since 1945 Postwar : A History of Europe Since 1945
  5. The Cold War : A New History The Cold War : A New History

ASIN: 0679746323
Release Date: 2006-11-14

Amazon.com

In the epilogue to her biography of Mao Tse-tung, Jung Chang and her husband and cowriter Jon Halliday lament that, "Today, Mao's portrait and his corpse still dominate Tiananmen Square in the heart of the Chinese capital." For Chang, author of Wild Swans, this fact is an affront, not just to history, but to decency. Mao: The Unknown Story does not contain a formal dedication, but it is clear that Chang is writing to honor the millions of Chinese who fell victim to Mao's drive for absolute power in his 50-plus-year struggle to dominate China and the 20th-century political landscape. From the outset, Chang and Halliday are determined to shatter the "myth" of Mao, and they succeed with the force, not just of moral outrage, but of facts. The result is a book, more indictment than portrait, that paints Mao as a brutal totalitarian, a thug, who unleashed Stalin-like purges of millions with relish and without compunction, all for his personal gain. Through the authors' unrelenting lens even his would-be heroism as the leader of the Long March and father of modern China is exposed as reckless opportunism, subjecting his charges to months of unnecessary hardship in order to maintain the upper hand over his rival, Chang Kuo-tao, an experienced military commander.

Using exhaustive research in archives all over the world, Chang and Halliday recast Mao's ascent to power and subsequent grip on China in the context of global events. Sino-Soviet relations, the strengths and weakness of Chiang Kai-shek, the Japanese invasion of China, World War II, the Korean War, the disastrous Great Leap Forward, the vicious Cultural Revolution, the Vietnam War, Nixon's visit, and the constant, unending purges all, understandably, provide the backdrop for Mao's unscrupulous but invincible political maneuverings and betrayals. No one escaped unharmed. Rivals, families, peasants, city dwellers, soldiers, and lifelong allies such as Chou En-lai were all sacrificed to Mao's ambition and paranoia. Appropriately, the authors' consciences are appalled. Their biggest fear is that Mao will escape the global condemnation and infamy he deserves. Their astonishing book will go a long way to ensure that the pendulum of history will adjust itself accordingly. --Silvana Tropea


10 Second Interview: A Few Words with Jung Chang and Jon Halliday

Q: From idea to finished book, how long did Mao: The Unknown Story take to research and write?
A: Over a decade.

Q: What was your writing process like? How did you two collaborate on this project?
A: The research shook itself out by language. Jung did all the Chinese-language research, and Jon did the other languages, of which Russian was the most important, as Mao had a long-term intimate relationship with Stalin. After our research trips around the world, we would work in our separate studies in London. We would then rendezvous at lunch to exchange discoveries.

Q: Do you have any thoughts about how the book is, or will be received in China? Did that play a part in your writing of the book?
A: The book is banned in China, because the current Communist regime is fiercely perpetuating the myth of Mao. Today Mao's portrait and his corpse still dominate Tiananmen Square in the heart of Beijing, and the regime declares itself to be Mao's heir. The government blocked the distribution of an issue of The Far Eastern Economic Review, and told the magazine's owners, Dow Jones, that this was because that issue contained a review of our book. The regime also tore the review of our book out of The Economist magazine that was going to (very restricted) newsstands. We are not surprised that the book is banned. The regime's attitude had no influence on how we wrote the book. We hope many copies will find their way into China.

Q: What is the one thing you hope readers get from your book?
A: Mao was responsible for the deaths of well over 70 million Chinese in peacetime, and he was bent on dominating the world. As China is today emerging as an economic and military power, the world can never regard it as a benign force unless Beijing rejects Mao and all his legacies. We hope our book will help push China in this direction by telling the truth about Mao.

Breakdown of a BIG Book: 5 Things You'll Learn from Mao: The Unknown Story

1. Mao became a Communist at the age of 27 for purely pragmatic reasons: a job and income from the Russians.

2. Far from organizing the Long March in 1934, Mao was nearly left behind by his colleagues who could not stand him and had tried to oust him several times. The aim of the March was to link up with Russia to get arms. The Reds survived the March because Chiang Kai-shek let them, in a secret horse-trade for his son and heir, whom Stalin was holding hostage in Russia.

3. Mao grew opium on a large scale.

4. After he conquered China, Mao's over-riding goal was to become a superpower and dominate the world: "Control the Earth," as he put it.

5. Mao caused the greatest famine in history by exporting food to Russia to buy nuclear and arms industries: 38 million people were starved and slave-driven to death in 1958-61. Mao knew exactly what was happening, saying: "half of China may well have to die."




Book Description

The most authoritative life of the Chinese leader every written, Mao: The Unknown Story is based on a decade of research, and on interviews with many of Mao’s close circle in China who have never talked before — and with virtually everyone outside China who had significant dealings with him. It is full of startling revelations, exploding the myth of the Long March, and showing a completely unknown Mao: he was not driven by idealism or ideology; his intimate and intricate relationship with Stalin went back to the 1920s, ultimately bringing him to power; he welcomed Japanese occupation of much of China; and he schemed, poisoned, and blackmailed to get his way. After Mao conquered China in 1949, his secret goal was to dominate the world. In chasing this dream he caused the deaths of 38 million people in the greatest famine in history. In all, well over 70 million Chinese perished under Mao’s rule — in peacetime.

Customer Reviews:

5 out of 5 stars Evil Mao.......2007-09-24

Very well researched book. Gives you an overlook on the real Mao and how the rest of the world misinterpreted him. Shows how America was superficial in assessing how the real Mao would be and how it applied pressure on Chiang Kai Shek to enforce cease fire on Mao's critical turning point of the civil war thus making it possible for Mao to conquer China. Mao killed his colleagues and his enemies alike for the sole purpose of gaining and retaining power. All means were legitimate in his eyes to achieve that goal. It looks like we never learn from these mistakes. This attitude makes us helping the Taliban to be a prominent force and Al Qaeda flourish in Iraq, a place they have never been before the invasion. Easy reading with simple language with tons of new info reflecting our lack of knowledge about someone so important.

1 out of 5 stars what a joke!.......2007-09-22

The newest tome of bathroom entertainment. "Entertainment" is what this is. you know when movies are "based on true events"? this book is like that. I don't blame the authors for trying to make a couple of dollars by sensationalize and distort history to their liking. no one can really say their version of history is 100% accurate, but this is almost cartoonish in nature. I just hope some poor person don't actually believes any of this non-sense.

So read this book for fun, but please don't take it seriously, and god forbid please do not bring anything up from this in a discussion with your friends or family who are knowledgeable in Chinese history. You will be laughed right out of the room.

4 out of 5 stars The Black Book...and the Red one... .......2007-09-14

Amidst all the controversy over this book, I can't fault the authors for their claim of Mao's responsibility for 70 million domestic peacetime deaths. That figure is indeed confirmed by the Black Book of Communism, which was written by avowed leftists.

It seems such a short time since it was oh so trendy to be seen carrying around campus a copy of the Chairman's Little Red Book.

4 out of 5 stars Caveats, but well worth the price of admission.......2007-09-13

If nothing else, this book is deeply fascinating. The questions of historical precision are raised in even a rudimentary Google search for reviews, yet this is still a book very much worth your time to read. The authors make it eminently obvious they hold no love for Mao, but partisanship or bias are not synonyms for dishonesty - they simply require the reader to attach qualifications to the conclusions. We would not discard out of hand a biography of Hitler written by an Auschwitz Jew.

Concerns for the precision of her statistics and conclusions are justified, but only to a point. Discrepancies, such as whether or not the Great Leap Forward killed 30 million or 38 million, do potentially indicate scholarly sloppiness, but myopic focus on C&H's precision only validates Stalin's notation that once you kill enough people, they're only numbers. I'm willing to accept they exaggerated their numbers, but frankly, I don't care. I'm more concerned about a lot of people getting killed than about exactly how many it was.

Ultimately, this book asks you to weigh the benefits of Mao's life by exposing his awesome sins. Exaggerated though some numbers might be, and partisan though the arguments are, to dismiss this portrait of Mao on those grounds only encourages history to repeat itself. I don't disagree with the other reviews that this books neglects the "benefits" of Mao's reign, but starting down that road is extremely dangerous. By turning analysis of Mao's reign into a cost-benefit analysis between the lives he killed and the lives he raised from poverty or the advances in issues like women's rights, we only make it easier to repeat these mistakes. I am far more comfortable using Mao's biography as a morality tale that damns him unconditionally than I am with utilitarian calculations, however correct or honest those calculations might be. I appreciate the loss in nuance, historical accuracy, and objectivity, but are we really comfortable with the idea that presiding over the deaths of tens of millions of people is ultimately justified if future generations are lifted from poverty?

This is a book with caveats, no doubt, but also a book that makes one think that if you were given one chance to change the course of history, there might be few better choices than wishing Mao was never born.

2 out of 5 stars Very disapointing.......2007-09-06

Before I started reading this book I had great expectations. I knew nothing about Mao at the time and this book seemed like a good place to start. This was a mistake. To make it short, the author's aim is not to tell the story of Mao, but to break his reputation. According to the author, Mao did not believe in communism, he just happened to join the communist party (although when he did join there were very few members and nothing really worth to take advantage of), he was not a great military commander (the writer explains that in all the battles that Mao won, he won because those that were against him were either spies or idiots, or because he was lucky, or because someone from the communist party did all the work and Mao took credit). The author also tried to tell us that Mao was lucky to acquire the nuclear bomb and he actually miscalculated but as in most cases luck was by his side. The issue that the writer really failed to tackle was that when Mao came to power China was in a terrible mess and no one really ruled it. The Russians and the Japanese attacked when they wished and no one could stop them. By the time Mao died China was one of the strongest countries in the world and was united under a single leadership. Yes Mao was a mass murderer, but that doesnt mean he cant be smart or calculating.
How Mao Died: A Chinese Love-story
Average customer rating: 5 out of 5 stars
  • How Mao Died : love, loss and betrayal
How Mao Died: A Chinese Love-story
David E.R. George
Manufacturer: BookSurge Publishing
ProductGroup: Book
Binding: Paperback

GeneralGeneral | Romance | Subjects | Books
GeneralGeneral | Contemporary | Romance | Subjects | Books
Similar Items:
  1. Mao's Last Revolution Mao's Last Revolution

ASIN: 1921019565
Release Date: 2006-06-21

Book Description

David George really did go to live and work in China. One of his students, Yin Wei (The Girl With The Swallow Tail Plaits), gives him her Journal, says she was there when Ed Snow interviewed Mao in the caves of Yenan and created his legend - and at the end when his disciples, betrayed, plotted his death. . .

Customer Reviews:

5 out of 5 stars How Mao Died : love, loss and betrayal.......2006-07-13

David George calls his novel How Mao Died "reality fiction". Why not? We have reality TV. But he means more by calling his blend of biography, autobiography, history and fiction by this term. This book is a breath of fresh air in a recent spate of books on Mao which would have us believe he was simply a tyrant and murderer: they have been written by people who suffered during the Cultural Revolution and now want to get their own back. But as George reminds us, they are no more true - or false - than the old accounts of Mao the poet-priest. Besides, if Mao was just a tyrant, why did millions of people willingly choose to take up his cause and follow him?

George speaks from the vantage point of somebody who lived and worked in China during the 1970s, was a believer who became disillusioned, and is neither pro nor anti Mao. He avoids the pettiness of "taking sides" in order to pose the crucial questions: "Why did so many believe?" "What happens when we are left disillusioned--is it better to have believed and lost than never to have believed at all?" In the contemporary world where cynicism seems to prevail and to believe is naïve, these questions are more than historical.

All of the main characters in How Mao Died: Edgar Snow (the American journalist who made Mao famous), Yin-Wei (the "Girl with the swallow-tail plaits"), and David George himself had to learn how to live after the dream has faded and it is this which is the great strength of this novel: it faces reality in all its brutality but does not let reality dictate its sad message: How did the swallow lose its tail? Let Yin Wei tell us: "Once they had a single tail like all other birds, but when the winter came and the cold, they huddled in their caves until their tails froze to the walls of their nests. They could not move; they could only sing and they did, very beautifully. People heard them, came to catch them. To get away, they had to flap their wings very hard until they tore their body away from their frozen tail. Now they have two tails - one left, one right, so that whichever way the wind blows, they can find their way home.
When the spring comes and then fades too soon, they remember the winter they lost their tails and the songs they sang..."
How Mao Died is beautifully written, rich and complex: it is a tale of how history is made, how people are mislead but, in the end, a tale of hope; in the end a love story.

:

Spring Silkworms and Other Stories
Average customer rating: Not rated
    Spring Silkworms and Other Stories
    tun mao
    Manufacturer: Foreign Languages Press
    ProductGroup: Book
    Binding: Unknown Binding
    ASIN: B0000CPGWT
    Spring silkworms and other stories,
    Average customer rating: Not rated
      Spring silkworms and other stories,
      Tun Mao
      Manufacturer: Foreign Languages Press
      ProductGroup: Book
      Binding: Unknown Binding

      GeneralGeneral | World Literature | Literature & Fiction | Subjects | Books
      ASIN: B0006AV8PK
      Twelve towers : short stories
      Average customer rating: Not rated
        Twelve towers : short stories
        Nathan K. Mao
        Manufacturer: Chinese University Press ; distributed by the University of Washington Press
        ProductGroup: Book
        Binding: Unknown Binding
        ASIN: 9622011713
        Chang, Jung & Halliday, Jon. Mao; the unknown story.(Young adult review)(Book review): An article from: Kliatt
        Average customer rating: Not rated
          Chang, Jung & Halliday, Jon. Mao; the unknown story.(Young adult review)(Book review): An article from: Kliatt
          Avi Kramer
          Manufacturer: Thomson Gale
          ProductGroup: Book
          Binding: Digital
          ASIN: B000VN7IOM
          Release Date: 2007-09-01

          Book Description

          This digital document is an article from Kliatt, published by Thomson Gale on March 1, 2007. The length of the article is 483 words. The page length shown above is based on a typical 300-word page. The article is delivered in HTML format and is available in your Amazon.com Digital Locker immediately after purchase. You can view it with any web browser.

          Citation Details
          Title: Chang, Jung & Halliday, Jon. Mao; the unknown story.(Young adult review)(Book review)
          Author: Avi Kramer
          Publication: Kliatt (Magazine/Journal)
          Date: March 1, 2007
          Publisher: Thomson Gale
          Volume: 41 Issue: 2 Page: 33(2)

          Article Type: Book review, Young adult review

          Distributed by Thomson Gale
          Helmsman from Hell; Mao Zedong was "a genius at insurrection.".(Mao: The Unknown Story )(Book review) : An article from: The Weekly Standard
          Average customer rating: Not rated
            Helmsman from Hell; Mao Zedong was "a genius at insurrection.".(Mao: The Unknown Story )(Book review) : An article from: The Weekly Standard
            Max Boot
            Manufacturer: Thomson Gale
            ProductGroup: Book
            Binding: Digital
            ASIN: B000FNVUYM
            Release Date: 2006-05-10

            Book Description

            This digital document is an article from The Weekly Standard, published by Thomson Gale on May 1, 2006. The length of the article is 2570 words. The page length shown above is based on a typical 300-word page. The article is delivered in HTML format and is available in your Amazon.com Digital Locker immediately after purchase. You can view it with any web browser.

            Citation Details
            Title: Helmsman from Hell; Mao Zedong was "a genius at insurrection.".(Mao: The Unknown Story )(Book review)
            Author: Max Boot
            Publication: The Weekly Standard (Magazine/Journal)
            Date: May 1, 2006
            Publisher: Thomson Gale
            Page: NA

            Article Type: Book review

            Distributed by Thomson Gale
            Mao & the Maoists.(Book Review) : An article from: New Criterion
            Average customer rating: Not rated
              Mao & the Maoists.(Book Review) : An article from: New Criterion
              Keith Windschuttle
              Manufacturer: Thomson Gale
              ProductGroup: Book
              Binding: Digital

              GeneralGeneral | Literature & Fiction | Subjects | Books | Classics | Comic | Contemporary | Literary
              GeneralGeneral | Politics | Nonfiction | Subjects | Books
              GeneralGeneral | Literature & Fiction | Subjects | e-Docs | Formats | Books
              Political SciencePolitical Science | Nonfiction | Subjects | e-Docs | Formats | Books
              GeneralGeneral | Nonfiction | HTML | Formats | e-Docs | Formats | Books
              Political SciencePolitical Science | Nonfiction | HTML | Formats | e-Docs | Formats | Books
              ASIN: B000DZVB6Y
              Release Date: 2005-12-20

              Book Description

              This digital document is an article from New Criterion, published by Thomson Gale on October 1, 2005. The length of the article is 6448 words. The page length shown above is based on a typical 300-word page. The article is delivered in HTML format and is available in your Amazon.com Digital Locker immediately after purchase. You can view it with any web browser.

              Citation Details
              Title: Mao & the Maoists.(Book Review)
              Author: Keith Windschuttle
              Publication: New Criterion (Magazine/Journal)
              Date: October 1, 2005
              Publisher: Thomson Gale
              Volume: 24 Issue: 2 Page: 4(10)

              Article Type: Book Review

              Distributed by Thomson Gale
              Mao: The Unknown Story (Unabridged)
              Average customer rating: Not rated
                Mao: The Unknown Story (Unabridged)
                Halliday, Jung, Jon Chang
                Manufacturer: audible.com
                ProductGroup: Book
                Binding: Audio Download
                ASIN: B000FDJ3AK
                Mao: The Unknown Story.(Book Review) : An article from: The Cato Journal
                Average customer rating: Not rated
                  Mao: The Unknown Story.(Book Review) : An article from: The Cato Journal
                  Jude Blanchette
                  Manufacturer: Thomson Gale
                  ProductGroup: Book
                  Binding: Digital

                  HistoryHistory | Subjects | Books | Africa | Americas | Ancient | Arctic & Antarctica | Asia | Audiobooks | Australia & Oceania | Books on CD | Books on Cassette | Europe | Gay & Lesbian | Historical Study | Large Print | Middle East | Military | Military Science | Russia | United States | World
                  GeneralGeneral | Politics | Nonfiction | Subjects | Books
                  Political SciencePolitical Science | Nonfiction | Subjects | e-Docs | Formats | Books
                  GeneralGeneral | History | Subjects | e-Docs | Formats | Books
                  GeneralGeneral | History | HTML | Formats | e-Docs | Formats | Books
                  GeneralGeneral | Nonfiction | HTML | Formats | e-Docs | Formats | Books
                  Political SciencePolitical Science | Nonfiction | HTML | Formats | e-Docs | Formats | Books
                  ASIN: B000E1N6RO
                  Release Date: 2005-12-27

                  Book Description

                  This digital document is an article from The Cato Journal, published by Thomson Gale on September 22, 2005. The length of the article is 1268 words. The page length shown above is based on a typical 300-word page. The article is delivered in HTML format and is available in your Amazon.com Digital Locker immediately after purchase. You can view it with any web browser.

                  Citation Details
                  Title: Mao: The Unknown Story.(Book Review)
                  Author: Jude Blanchette
                  Publication: The Cato Journal (Magazine/Journal)
                  Date: September 22, 2005
                  Publisher: Thomson Gale
                  Volume: 25 Issue: 3 Page: 639(3)

                  Article Type: Book Review

                  Distributed by Thomson Gale

                  When the Yankees Came: Conflict and Chaos in the Occupied South, 1861-1865 (Civil War America)
                  Average customer rating: 5 out of 5 stars
                  • Excellent work by engaging author...
                  • Very Good Look at the South after Union Occupation
                  When the Yankees Came: Conflict and Chaos in the Occupied South, 1861-1865 (Civil War America)
                  Stephen V. Ash
                  Manufacturer: The University of North Carolina Press
                  ProductGroup: Book
                  Binding: Paperback

                  GeneralGeneral | 19th Century | United States | Americas | History | Subjects | Books
                  GeneralGeneral | United States | Americas | History | Subjects | Books
                  GeneralGeneral | State & Local | United States | Americas | History | Subjects | Books
                  SouthSouth | State & Local | United States | Americas | History | Subjects | Books
                  GeneralGeneral | Civil War | United States | Americas | History | Subjects | Books
                  GeneralGeneral | Americas | History | Subjects | Books
                  GeneralGeneral | Military | History | Subjects | Books
                  All TitlesAll Titles | Qualifying Textbooks - Fall 2007 | Stores | Books
                  Similar Items:
                  1. Politics and Power in a Slave Society: Alabama , 1800-1860 Politics and Power in a Slave Society: Alabama , 1800-1860
                  2. Reluctant Confederates: Upper South Unionists in the Secession Crisis (Fred W Morrison Series in Southern Studies) Reluctant Confederates: Upper South Unionists in the Secession Crisis (Fred W Morrison Series in Southern Studies)
                  3. Rehearsal for Reconstruction: The Port Royal Experiment (Galaxy Books) Rehearsal for Reconstruction: The Port Royal Experiment (Galaxy Books)
                  4. The Hard Hand of War The Hard Hand of War
                  5. Speculators and Slaves: Masters, Traders, and Slaves in the Old South Speculators and Slaves: Masters, Traders, and Slaves in the Old South

                  ASIN: 080784795X
                  Release Date: 1999-08-04

                  Book Description

                  Southerners whose communities were invaded by the Union army during the Civil War endured a profoundly painful ordeal. For most, the coming of the Yankees was a nightmare become real; for some, it was the answer to a prayer. But as Stephen Ash argues, for all, invasion and occupation were essential parts of the experience of defeat that helped shape the southern postwar mentality.

                  When the Yankees Came is the first comprehensive study of the occupied South, bringing to light a wealth of new information about the southern home front. Among the intriguing topics Ash explores are guerrilla warfare and other forms of civilian resistance; the evolution of Union occupation policy from leniency to repression; the impact of occupation on families, churches, and local government; and conflicts between southern aristocrats and poor whites. In analyzing these topics, Ash examines events from the perspective not only of southerners but also of the northern invaders, and he shows how the experiences of southerners differed according to their distance from a garrisoned town.

                  Customer Reviews:

                  5 out of 5 stars Excellent work by engaging author..........2006-04-06

                  In this book, Ash analyzes the Southern experience in areas invaded by Union troops during the Civil War. Whereas most other studies on this subject deal with a specific town or locality, Ash's book presents an inclusive synthesis that examines the commonalities of the occupation throughout the South. Three main themes direct his study of occupation. One examines how Northern policies regarding the South during occupation developed over the course of the war. Another theme appraises how three different geographical segments of the South experienced occupation (garrison towns, the Confederate frontier, and no-man's land). Finally, Ash looks at how occupation by Federal forces led to internal conflicts between Southerners of varied political, social, and economic groups.
                  In Ash's study, three important hallmarks of the South were its social hierarchy, its rural communalism, and its race relations. These elements worked in combination to create a unique society that Northern invaders perceived as both backward and foreign. Because of the cultural disparities between the North and the South, the arrival of Union occupying troops was a greatly feared occurrence by Southerners. However, initial Southern interactions with Union troops proved to be less volatile than was originally thought. Despite Northern attempts to remain equitable and lenient within occupied areas, Southern recalcitrance persisted. The continuation of these rebellious attitudes forced Union troops to adopt a harsher policy in their administration of the occupied South, leading to further antagonism between the Union military and Southerners. The "hard policy" of Union occupation also increased existing internal conflicts in the South, such as those between slaves and their masters, Unionists and their secessionist neighbors, and poor whites and the propertied elites. Thus, with the Union control of the South and the disruption caused by this occupation, the established elements of Southern culture (social hierarchy, rural communalism, race relations) could no longer provide a completely cohesive society.

                  5 out of 5 stars Very Good Look at the South after Union Occupation.......2000-06-01

                  A very interesting view of the other side of the Civil War. Ash takes the reader on a trip to the South and shows how life changed after the Union Army invaded. The book gives an overall look at the entire South, showing exactly how different regions were effected. Also includes many quotes from actual residents and cites from Southern newspapers, each giving the reader a true vision of what it was like to live there during the Civil War. A wonderful addition to a Civil War collection, especially if you are interested in the South.

                  That Noble Dream: The 'Objectivity Question' and the American Historical Profession (Ideas in Context)
                  Average customer rating: 3 out of 5 stars
                  • How to read write and study history
                  • Valuable, but only with cautious scrutiny
                  • Deliberate misrepresentation of evidence
                  • Must read for every historian
                  • deconstructing decronstruction
                  That Noble Dream: The 'Objectivity Question' and the American Historical Profession (Ideas in Context)
                  Peter Novick
                  Manufacturer: Cambridge University Press
                  ProductGroup: Book
                  Binding: Paperback

                  HistoriographyHistoriography | Historical Study | History | Subjects | Books
                  History of IdeasHistory of Ideas | Historical Study | History | Subjects | Books
                  GeneralGeneral | Politics | Nonfiction | Subjects | Books
                  History & TheoryHistory & Theory | Politics | Nonfiction | Subjects | Books
                  All TitlesAll Titles | Qualifying Textbooks - Fall 2007 | Stores | Books
                  NonfictionNonfiction | Qualifying Textbooks - Fall 2007 | Stores | Books
                  Similar Items:
                  1. Telling the Truth About History Telling the Truth About History
                  2. Historiography in the Twentieth Century: From Scientific Objectivity to the Postmodern Challenge Historiography in the Twentieth Century: From Scientific Objectivity to the Postmodern Challenge
                  3. Cheese and the Worms Cheese and the Worms
                  4. Imagined Communities: Reflections on the Origin and Spread of Nationalism, New Edition Imagined Communities: Reflections on the Origin and Spread of Nationalism, New Edition
                  5. What Is History? What Is History?

                  ASIN: 0521357454

                  Book Description

                  The aspiration to relate the past "as it really happened" has been the central goal of American professional historians since the late nineteenth century. In this remarkable history of the profession, Peter Novick shows how the idea and ideal of objectivity was elaborated, challenged, modified, and defended over the past century. Drawing on the unpublished correspondence as well as the published writing of hundreds of American historians, this book is a richly textured account of what American historians have thought they were doing, or ought to be doing, when they wrote history--how their principles influenced their practice and practical exigencies influenced their principles. Published with the support of the Exxon Education Foundation.

                  Customer Reviews:

                  3 out of 5 stars How to read write and study history.......2006-12-27

                  Novick's piece is a good introduction to how history should be read, written and studied. I was assigned this book in my undergraduate historical methods course and found it to be useful in understanding why history is more complex than most people believe. Historians can not simply read one book on a subject and take as gospel. In graduate school I was assigned Mark Gilderhus' History and Historians, David Fischer's Historians' Fallacies, Davidson and Lytle's After the Fact and Richard Evans' In Defense of History which helped me continue the journey started with Novick.

                  1 out of 5 stars Valuable, but only with cautious scrutiny.......2006-06-26

                  This author writing about objectivity seemed to really struggle with it himself. There is so much bias present that it's difficult to discern when Novick is speaking or when he is merely "echoing" the sentiments of others. Whatever the case, he simulatenously presents a valuable, if dense, tome about the history of history while, if it's taken at face value, failing to provide a fair and equitable account of the "objective truth."

                  2 out of 5 stars Deliberate misrepresentation of evidence.......2004-04-15

                  Deliberate misrepresentation of evidence and plagiarism are among the most grievous sins a historian may commit. Not only would this do a disservice to our understanding of the past, but of the present and even the future. Peter Novick's treatment of Charles Beard's critics is a case to these points. Just as Hofstadter and others claimed that Beard had misrepresented the evidence, a similar claim may be made that Novick has misrepresented Hofstadter's critique of Beard. In his book, That Noble Dream, The "Objectivity Question" and the American Historical Profession, Novick staunchly defends Beard and Becker from their critics by attacking their credibility and dismissing the shortcomings of the progressives. Along the way Novick makes an enticing argument that History as a discipline has been fragmenting, it had been endlessly whittled down internally, and he concluded by proudly proclaiming that history is dead. And his argument is strengthened by its appearance as formal historical writing. But his provocative view of History's fragmentation, is, as Beard would say, only one interpretation. And we must attend to the particular matter of Novick's misrepresentation of Hofstadter's critique of Beard. From that, we might more clearly evaluate Novick's position. Novick not only fails to cite his use of Hofstadter's text entirely honestly, he is guilty of misrepresenting him as well. In The Progressive Historians, Turner, Beard, Parrington, Hofstadter wrote:
                  In 1938, when a considerable number of intellectuals were queried by the editors of the New Republic for its symposium on "Books That Changed Our Minds," Beard's name ranked second only to Veblen's (and ahead of Dewey's and Freud's) among thinkers acknowledged with gratitude, and the two titles most often mentioned by the respondents were The Theory of the Leisure Class and An Economic Interpretation of the Constitution. (220)
                  Though Novick provides the correct title for the source of this information, he nowhere suggests that the following are any but his own words:
                  In the 1938 New Republic symposium on "Books That Changed our Minds," Beard was ranked second only to Veblen in influence, ahead of Dewey and Freud. (240)

                  Novick's phrasing certainly wouldn't pass "the smell test" for plagiarism in a historical writing course. He is in the very least guilty of shoddy editing (Stephen Ambrose was skewered for similar shortcomings in his work). As such, this cracks open an unpleasant door for our perception of Novick's work, namely the door of questionable credibility. Though Novick uses the form of historical writing this not presuppose that he is not inaccurate, unbiased, or unprofessional in his methodology. Indeed, his book's premise is that historians cannot be objective; hence, can we believe his is an objective representation? He misrepresented the context of Hofstadter's work and used his words as his own. Is this laudable scholarship?

                  5 out of 5 stars Must read for every historian.......2003-12-10

                  When a professor assigned Peter Novick's "That Noble Dream" as one of the last readings in one of my seminars, I blanched. Who, I inwardly groaned, would force students to read a book this huge in the waning weeks of the semester, a time when the heavy weight of tests, papers, and grading exams rests on your shoulders? "Look at the size of that font! How in the heck are we supposed to get through that thing in a week?" wailed a fellow sufferer, echoing what we all thought as we blearily thumbed through the book. Initial skimming seemed to confirm that this would be one of those scholarly books that take years off your life even as you promptly forget what you read a mere five minutes ago. Now, I've done some power reading during my tenure as an undergraduate and graduate student; I once cruised through Herodotus in two days and Thucycdides in even less time. You learn to accept things like this in the unnatural world of the academy. With lengthy papers due at the same time I opened this book, I decided to power stuff this one. Even now I can hear the knowing snickers of graduate students across the nation who may be reading this review, seminar hardened souls amused to no end that I actually assumed I had to READ the book. I can hear the chorus: just skim through it over the course of a few hours, learn the main argument, take a few notes, and nod sagely in class.

                  Well, a funny thing happened on the way to the end of Novick's treatment of the noble profession: I rapidly discovered that this book is brilliant; a veritable cathedral of razor sharp analysis, amazing use of primary source material, and all written with one eye firmly planted on the bigger picture. What human being is capable of this Gibbonesque treatment of the American historical profession? Apparently a University of Chicago professor with a whole lot of time on his hands, a man whose primary field of research has little to do with American history. Well, Gibbon's inspiration for his enormous masterwork came from a visit to the ruins of Rome, so why not an equally impressive history from someone working outside his field? A comprehensive summary of the book is an exercise in futility here, but I think I should take a stab at it since I am studying history and often must summarize scads of material into a few precious paragraphs. My review will be inferior anyway compared to the extremely insightful essay found below on this very page.

                  Novick begins with an examination of the German methodologies of history---an appropriate starting point because Americans wishing to study the past on an advanced level in the nineteenth century needed to go to school in Europe---in an attempt to discover how the first generation of professional American historians approached their craft. To be sure, amateur historians like Parkman, Prescott, and Adams wrote narrative histories on such huge topics as North America, Mexico, and the early governments of the United States. But in an age where scientific methods came of age, men stood up and rejected the narratives, believing that the very same techniques could, and should, be applied to the study of history. An age of strict objectivity called for an equally rigorous impartiality in looking at the past, and the first trained historians here did so with relish. Worshipping the phrase "wie es eigentlich gewesen," or studying history "as it really was," our academic ancestors attempted to collect as much factual evidence from historical sources as possible, crafting "building blocks" of history so that in the near future men could unearth the universal truth by putting these blocks together. Amusingly, Novick discovers that the American historians misunderstood this magical phrase, that it should translate as "as it essentially is," a different ballgame altogether that means a historian should employ his intuition in his studies. Since this is the exact opposite of how our historians applied the phrase, the entire edifice of our profession balances upon a translation error! Study hard for those proficiency exams, my friends!

                  Novick's scrupulous treatment of the succeeding years of the profession reveals metatectonic (a word that appears throughout the book, and frankly, I love it and use it whenever possible) themes, but the biggest one may be that big social changes lead to big changes in the academy. While many scholars like to think they create rather than react to societal transformations, Novick proves them wrong repeatedly. War, for example, served to bring about sea changes in how historians studied history. The nightmares unfolding at places like Ypres and the concomitant moral discord after that war led to a short period of "doubt casting" in every field of western human endeavor. Things that seemed indisputable before millions died in the mud suddenly assumed a worrisome etherealness, a hazy uncertainty that ushered in the beginnings of relativism. The Second World War and the subsequent Cold War, with its need for absolute convictions (Hitler and Communism bad, Us good), temporarily quashed proto-relativism in favor of consensus. We are where we are at now, in an age of unbridled relativism, "social construction," and "deconstruction" because of the Vietnam War and the rise of the New Left historians. Novick outlines it all in one page after another, pages rife with the words of the historians who were there when it happened.

                  A short review fails to relate the impressiveness of this work. There are a few omissions here, one being the pedagogical functions of history as mentioned in a previous review. The other problem concerns the shortage of information about earning credentials in the profession. For information on how much fun that process is, you need to look at Theodore Hamerow's curmudgeonly treatment of life in graduate school, "Reflections on History and Historians."

                  3 out of 5 stars deconstructing decronstruction.......2003-10-27

                  For all the attention given in recent years to the social context of discourse, remarkably little has been given to the way in which the context of modern academia shapes the way we think about the past. One of the really satisfying things about Peter Novick's 1988 book, That Noble Dream, his history of the American historical profession, is the way-despite its tendency toward relativism and complacency-it turns the armamentarium of critical historical scholarship against the activity of critical historical scholarship itself. One can't read the book and not come away with a deep sense of how much our sense of the past has been hopelessly muddled by the internal imperatives of the profession. It is by endless cycles of cutting and slashing, revising and revisioning, "neo"ing and "post"ing, interrogating and all the rest of the tedious professional jargon, that reputations are made, empires are built, careers are jumpstarted, and-not to put too fine a point on it-tenure is won and promotion secured. The dynamic of revisionism, a dynamic of churning, incessant novelty, serves the cause of academic careerism even more than it does the cause of political correctness. And such careerism and specialization has the effect of stamping out an appreciative sense of the past.
                  That noble dream: the objectivity question and the American historical profession.
                  Average customer rating: Not rated
                    That noble dream: the objectivity question and the American historical profession.
                    Peter Novick
                    Manufacturer: Cambridge UP, [
                    ProductGroup: Book
                    Binding: Paperback
                    ASIN: B000VM15QA

                    Mallards, a Pictorial Study
                    Average customer rating: Not rated
                      Mallards, a Pictorial Study
                      Tricia Veasey
                      Manufacturer: Schiffer Publishing
                      ProductGroup: Book
                      Binding: Paperback

                      GeneralGeneral | Biology | Biological Sciences | Science | Subjects | Books
                      OrnithologyOrnithology | Zoology | Biological Sciences | Science | Subjects | Books
                      GeneralGeneral | Birdwatching | Outdoors & Nature | Subjects | Books
                      Similar Items:
                      1. Wood Ducks: A Pictorial Study Wood Ducks: A Pictorial Study
                      2. Canvasbacks, a Pictorial Study Canvasbacks, a Pictorial Study
                      3. Geese a Pictorial Study Geese a Pictorial Study
                      4. The Great Gallery of Ducks and Other Waterfowl The Great Gallery of Ducks and Other Waterfowl

                      ASIN: 0887401163

                      Book Description

                      This handy book is a comprehensive photographic study of over 150 exquisite full-color pictures of mallards from diverse regions in many natural environments and body positions. Most of the ducks shown are wild, but there are a few penned. The majority are in full breeding plumage while a few drakes in moult are included for identification. Author/photographer Tricia Veasey demonstrates in Mallards both her enthusiasm for this species of bird and her photographic talent. She has created here an excellent source book for artists, carvers, taxidermists and naturalists alike that will delight and inspire each individually.

                      9" x 6" 166 color photos

                      Books:

                      1. MILO in the Woods of Wonder
                      2. Mothercare New Guide to Pregnancy and Child Care : An Illustrated Guide to Caring For Your Child from Preganancy Through Age Five
                      3. Mountains Beyond Mountains: The Quest of Dr. Paul Farmer, a Man Who Would Cure the World
                      4. Multiple Sclerosis: The Facts (Facts Series)
                      5. No Man's Land: Men's Changing Commitments to Family and Work
                      6. Oh, If Only That Old House Could Talk
                      7. Pandemonium: A Journey To The New World
                      8. Parenting Principles: From the Heart of a Pediatrician
                      9. Parenting Your Complex Child: Become a Powerful Advocate for the Autistic, Down Syndrome, PDD, Bipolar, or Other Special Needs Child
                      10. Perfectly Safe Home

                      Books Index

                      Books Home

                      Recommended Books

                      1. Jonathan Livingston Seagull
                      2. Girl in a Box
                      3. Casa Malaparte
                      4. D'Alembert's Principle: A Novel in Three Panels
                      5. Dress in Detail From Around the World
                      6. Evolution and Ecology of the Organism
                      7. Flying the Alaska Wild: The Adventures and Misadventures of an Alaska Bush Pilot
                      8. The Designer's Lexicon: The Illustrated Dictionary of Design, Printing, and Computer Terms
                      9. Chasing Ideas: The Fun of Freeing Your Child's Imagination
                      10. Phytates In Cereals & Legumes